Short answer: decide first whether you want an agency, which screens, supervises and covers absences, or a private hire, which can feel more personal but makes you the employer. Then interview in the home, spell out the exact tasks, check references, put the terms in writing, and start with a few hours of low-stress help before personal care. Pay attention to how your parent responds, not only to how the interview goes.
This guide summarizes advice from a family caregiver nonprofit, a home health provider, the Alzheimer’s Association, a county office for aging and the IRS. We are not lawyers, tax professionals or care professionals, and this is general information. We do not give prices here because costs vary widely by area and hours. Our aging in place cost guide has the cost side.
In this guide
Agency or private hire
| Topic | Agency | Private hire | From |
|---|---|---|---|
| Screening and hiring | The agency screens, hires and supervises staff. | The family is the employer and does the background checks. | Family Caregiver Alliance; VNS Health |
| When the aide is out | The agency can arrange backup coverage. | You find a replacement, often on short notice. | VNS Health |
| Payroll, taxes and insurance | Handled by the agency; ask exactly what is covered. | Your responsibility as the employer. | VNS Health; Alzheimer’s Association |
| Cost and feel | Usually costs more. | May cost less and feel more personal. | Broome County Office for Aging; VNS Health |
| If it is not a good fit | Ask the agency for a different aide. | You handle the change yourself. | VNS Health |
Family Caregiver Alliance also notes a shortage of trained caregivers and says that in rural areas hiring a friend or neighbor may be the most practical choice. If you are still deciding between help at home and a move, read home care vs assisted living.
Questions for an agency
Combining the lists from Family Caregiver Alliance, VNS Health and the Alzheimer’s Association:
- Licensing: Is the agency licensed in our state, and how long has it been in business?
- Screening: How do you screen caregivers, and do you run criminal background checks? Family Caregiver Alliance says that if you are uncomfortable with an agency’s screening, consider another provider.
- Training: What training and certifications do caregivers have, and does training cover dementia?
- Insurance: Are caregivers insured and bonded?
- Supervision: Does a nurse supervise care? Does a supervisor make drop-in visits, and how do you track clock-ins and care plans?
- Absences: What happens when an aide does not show up or is out sick?
- Matching: How do you match aides to clients, and what happens if my parent and the aide are not a good fit? Will we see the same caregivers?
- Care plan: Will there be a written care plan, and does a nurse visit before services begin?
- Problems: Who do we call with a problem, and is there 24-hour support?
- Money: What are the rates, any extra fees, any minimum hours, and how does billing work? Who pays payroll taxes? Family Caregiver Alliance suggests discussing rates and billing practices with the intake coordinator beforehand to avoid unexpected charges.
- References: Can we speak with current or former clients?
Questions for someone you hire yourself
- Experience: How many years have you done this, and with what conditions (dementia, mobility limits, incontinence)?
- Training: Do you have relevant training, and do you know first aid and CPR?
- Agency ties: Are you tied to an agency?
- Checks: Are you bonded, and will you agree to a background check? When you hire independently, VNS Health says you are responsible for the checks.
- Availability: What days and hours can you work, what is your minimum, and what is your backup plan when you are sick?
- Transport: Do you have transportation, and are you comfortable driving my parent?
- Specific duties: Are you comfortable with bathing, lifting, changing incontinence products and handling difficult behavior? The Broome County guide says to ask directly about each duty and not to assume a helper will do something you have not spelled out.
- Costs: What is your rate, and how and when do you expect to be paid?
- Licenses: Family Caregiver Alliance says to ask to see licenses where they apply.
How to run the interview
- Screen by phone first. The Broome County guide says you do not have to interview everyone and can politely decline applicants who do not seem suitable.
- Tell candidates the tasks, approximate hours and pay before you set an in-person meeting.
- Meet at the home where the work will happen. The Broome County guide and the Alzheimer’s Association both suggest having a trusted friend or relative with you so you can compare impressions afterwards.
- Interview several candidates if you are hiring independently, as VNS Health advises.
- Ask for at least three references, with at least two from people the applicant has worked for, and call them. Ask about reliability, trustworthiness and the quality of the work.
- Let your parent meet the finalist. Watch how the candidate speaks to your parent, not only to you.
Put it in writing
The Broome County guide recommends a written agreement even if you are not a lawyer. It says to include:
- the specific tasks, pay, hours and start and end dates;
- the notice needed to end the arrangement;
- behaviors that are not acceptable and conditions for immediate termination;
- details of personal care tasks, such as where supplies go and how your parent likes things done;
- signatures and dates for both sides, and who pays Social Security tax.
The guide also suggests keeping records of payments and of any discussions about problems, and keeping receipts if you pay in cash. It suggests asking your insurance agent whether your homeowner’s or renter’s policy covers an accident involving your helper.
If you are the employer: taxes
This section matters mainly for private hires. Agencies handle it themselves; ask them to confirm.
- The IRS says household workers are employees if you control not only what work is done but how it is done. Full- or part-time status and the way you pay do not change that.
- The IRS says that if you pay cash wages of $3,000 or more in 2026 to any one household employee, you generally must withhold 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare tax from wages and pay a matching 7.65% yourself. The IRS notes the threshold can change from year to year.
- The IRS says you do not withhold or pay Social Security and Medicare tax on wages paid to your spouse, your child under 21 or your parent (unless an exception applies), so check the page if a relative is the caregiver.
- Federal unemployment tax can also apply. The IRS says it generally applies if you pay more than $1,000 in cash wages in any calendar quarter of this or last year, on the first $7,000 paid to each employee.
- You report these taxes on Schedule H, attached to your Form 1040. The IRS also points to Publication 926, its household employer’s guide.
The IRS pages we read do not specifically mention caregivers, and state rules can differ. A tax professional can tell you how this applies to your case.
Red flags
The Broome County guide lists these warning signs, and VNS Health adds that the first weeks are the time to check whether the aide arrives on time, whether your parent feels comfortable and whether care meets your expectations:
- You feel uncomfortable with the person, or they cannot accept correction or communicate well.
- They lack tact, compassion or understanding of hearing or memory problems.
- They seem unable to handle emergencies or the work required.
- They are unreliable about attendance or do not give notice when they cannot come.
- You doubt they will do the work without supervision, or you doubt they can be trusted with belongings.
- They are not available when you need them, or are not affordable.
Family Caregiver Alliance says to trust your gut, and notes news stories about caregivers who were abusive, undertrained or unsupervised. If you suspect abuse or neglect, contact your local adult protective services or, in an emergency, 911.
The first weeks
- Start small. VNS Health suggests a few hours of companionship or household tasks before moving to personal care.
- Be present early on. Meet the caregiver before the first shift, as Family Caregiver Alliance suggests, and check in often at first.
- Give feedback quickly. The Broome County guide says to speak up soon after a problem, praise what is done well, and focus on actions rather than the person. Unless the behavior is dangerous, dishonest or clearly unacceptable, consider giving the helper a chance to improve.
- Expect to adjust. The same guide says you may need to try more than one helper. VNS Health says it is fine to ask for a change if the fit is wrong.
- Plan for emergencies. Leave a medication list, doctor numbers and your contact details where the caregiver can find them. Our free emergency info sheet below puts them on one page.
- Agree on a daily record. This is our own suggestion: ask the caregiver to tick off the day’s tasks and leave a short note. Our free caregiver daily checklist and log is a two-page PDF you can print.
If your parent has dementia
The Alzheimer’s Association adds several points. Ask whether the caregiver has dementia-specific training and experience. Describe a typical day and the likely challenges, and ask how they would handle them. Introduce them to your parent and watch the interaction. Keep communication open after hiring. See also our guides to dementia wandering at night and dementia monitoring devices.
The Aging Parent Emergency Info Sheet
Medications, contacts and legal info on one page, ready for a paramedic or hospital.
Common questions
Should I hire through an agency or hire someone privately?
It depends on how much of the work you want to take on. VNS Health says an agency handles screening, nurse oversight, backup coverage when an aide is out, and insurance, while hiring independently may feel more personal and can cost less but makes you the employer. Family Caregiver Alliance says that if you hire directly you are solely responsible for oversight, hiring, firing, background checks and certifications. The Broome County Office for Aging describes agencies as providing training and supervision but usually costing more.
How many references should I ask for?
The Broome County Office for Aging suggests at least three references, with at least two from people the applicant has worked for. It also says to check references thoroughly before you hire. Family Caregiver Alliance advises checking references from former employers.
Is a caregiver I hire myself an employee for tax purposes?
Possibly. The IRS says a worker is your employee if you control not only what work is done but how it is done. Its page on household employees does not specifically address caregivers, so check the IRS pages linked below or ask a tax professional about your case. The IRS says that for 2026, cash wages of $3,000 or more paid to one household employee generally trigger Social Security and Medicare tax, and that the threshold can change from year to year.
Does the home care agency pay the payroll taxes?
Ask. The Alzheimer’s Association lists “who pays payroll taxes” among the questions to put to an agency. The IRS says a worker supplied by an agency that controls the worker generally is not your household employee, but that is a general statement and not advice about your situation.
How do I start if my parent resists help from a stranger?
VNS Health suggests starting slowly, with a few hours of companionship or household help before moving to personal care, and watching the first few weeks. The Broome County guide says older people may resist help from strangers, that you may need to try more than one helper, and that letting the helper meet your parent socially before personal care begins can ease the transition. For more, read what to do when a parent refuses help.
What should I ask if my parent has dementia?
The Alzheimer’s Association suggests asking whether the caregiver has dementia training and experience, whether they know first aid and CPR, and how they would handle behavior changes. It also suggests describing a typical day and likely challenges, then asking how they would handle them, and introducing the caregiver to your parent so you can watch how they interact.
One important caveat
This guide is general information for family caregivers. It is not legal, tax or medical advice, and nobody on this site is a lawyer, accountant, doctor or nurse. Laws on home care licensing and household employment differ by state. We have not tested or rated any agency, and we do not recommend one here.
Sources
Family Caregiver Alliance, 10 Tips for Hiring In-Home Help Through an Agency and Smart Caregiving: Hiring In-Home Help. VNS Health, Hiring a Home Health Aide: A Guide for Family Caregivers. Alzheimer’s Association, Choosing an In-Home Care Professional (PDF). Broome County (NY) Office for Aging, Hiring Help brochure (PDF, 10/22). IRS, Topic no. 756, Employment taxes for household employees and Hiring household employees. We opened these pages in November 2026. The tables and checklists are our own summary. We welcome corrections through our contact page.
